Introducing Fair Work through ‘soft’ regulation in outsourced public service networks: Explaining unintended outcomes in the implementation of the Scottish living wage policy

Cunningham, Ian, James, Philip ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1500-9468, Baluch, Alina M. and Cullen, Anne-Marie (2022) Introducing Fair Work through ‘soft’ regulation in outsourced public service networks: Explaining unintended outcomes in the implementation of the Scottish living wage policy. Industrial Law Journal . ISSN 0305-9332 [Article] (Published online first) (doi:10.1093/indlaw/dwac023)

	PDF (Accepted paper) - Final accepted version (with author's formatting) Restricted to Repository staff and depositor only until 28 October 2024. Download (497kB)
	Microsoft Word (Accepted paper) - Final accepted version (with author's formatting) Restricted to Repository staff and depositor only Download (105kB)

Abstract

Using a regulatory analysis from Martinez Lucio and Mackenzie (2014 and 2016), this study contributes to debates concerning the capacity of ‘soft’ regulation to advance employment conditions and outcomes. This study explores the implementation of a real living wage policy for employees in outsourced Scottish social care. Despite employer compliance in implementing the living wage, it had a mixed impact on the income of workers, and did not improve staff recruitment and retention. The theoretical framework challenges recent optimistic views concerning the impact of such regulation by revealing unintended and problematic consequences, such as problems with differentials and providers walking away from contracts. It further reveals how actor roles, interests, power resources and inter-relationships, as well as surrounding structural contextual influences (austerity, marketisation and engrained values and processes in political settlements), interacted to shape these outcomes. Insights from this study include that ‘soft’ regulation was unable to create conditions for actors such as trade unions, employers and non-governmental organisations (NGOs) to colonise or seize the regulatory space to secure the full benefits of the SLW. The political settlement with Scottish Government allowed local authorities to retain coercive control over other actors in the regulatory space. Employers and trade unions were further hindered by lack of unity and continued isolation from decisions, respectively. Surrounding economic and ideological restrictions imposed by central UK government’s austerity agenda, and the retention of powers over employment regulation added to the failure of these ‘soft’ measures to increase pay and improve recruitment and retention in social care.

Actions (login required)

View Item

Statistics

DownloadsShow export options

Export as CSVXMLJSON

Activity Overview

6 month trend

9Downloads

6 month trend

60Hits

Additional statistics are available via IRStats2.