Do political connections matter? Empirical evidence from listed firms in Pakistan

Saeed, Mohammad Abubakr (2013) Do political connections matter? Empirical evidence from listed firms in Pakistan. PhD thesis, Middlesex University.

PDF - Final accepted version (with author's formatting)
Download (1MB) | Preview


The purpose of this thesis is to enhance understanding of the way in which political connections benefit or impair connected firms. For this purpose, the current study employs
the data of Pakistani listed non-financial firms from 2002–2010, and examines the impact of political connections on the economic life of individual firms. More specifically, this thesis
comprises three empirical studies: the first enquires into the way in which political connectedness influences firms’ access to finance; the second empirical chapter examines the
impact of political connections on the performance of the connected firms; and lastly, the third empirical chapter explores the channels through which connected politicians intervene
in business operations.
The findings in the first empirical chapter provide strong and robust evidence of preferential lending in the credit market. Political connectedness appears to be a determining factor of the
total and long-term leverage of the firms; nevertheless, short-term financing is indifferent to political connections. The study also finds that having connections with a winning politician
or politician affiliated to the winning parties (coalition) have a larger impact on the firm’s total and long-term leverage, thus implying that the benefits associated with political connections ultimately depend on electoral outcomes. In addition, firm size and business
group affiliation have increasing effect on the borrowing capabilities of the connected firms, whilst connections underplay the significance of collateral.
Through the use of an instrumental variable framework focused on the long-term panel and cross-sectional data of Pakistani listed firms, the second empirical chapter finds that political
connections distort the performance of the connected firms. Consistent results are found for various accounting and marketing measures of performance. So as to investigate the impact
of connectedness on performance in different political environments, the sample period is stratified into two contrasting government periods: autocratic; and democratic government
periods. The result is more pronounced in the autocratic regime, providing evidence of excessive managerial inefficiencies and rent-extraction of affiliated politicians in dictatorship
regime. It was also found that the performance of connected firms increased further if they belonged to business groups, whilst the large firms were subject to severe performance
distortions more so than small firms. Finally, those firms with low growth opportunities were more prone to the negative effects of political connectedness in terms of their performances.
The findings in the second empirical chapter (connections insert negative effect on the firm performance) inspired us to progress one step further and investigate the intriguing question:
what are the channels through which politicians interfere and distort the performance of the connected firms? In quest to answer this question, the last empirical chapter provides strong
and robust evidence of political intervention in the investment and employment decisions.
More specifically, results find the existence of investment inefficiencies and excessive employment in the connected firms. Importantly, the effect of political interference is more
pronounced for employment decisions, indicating the presence of clientelism in the Pakistani market, where politicians distribute job favours in exchange of electoral support. The study also reveals that connected firms with high growth opportunities experience political interference less often than their peers with low growth opportunities. Lastly, the economic cost of such political intervention in employment decisions is estimated to be 0.15% GDP annually.

Item Type: Thesis (PhD)
Additional Information: Thesis submitted to the Middlesex University for the degree of
Doctor of Philosophy
Research Areas: A. > Business School
B. > Theses
Item ID: 12361
Depositing User: Users 3197 not found.
Date Deposited: 14 Nov 2013 08:15
Last Modified: 31 May 2019 05:17

Actions (login required)

Edit Item Edit Item

Full text downloads (NB count will be zero if no full text documents are attached to the record)

Downloads per month over the past year